by James Hendler

In my blog of a couple days ago, I said what set me off was a blog by Rachel.  Let me be clear, I was in no way disagreeing with her view of the Semantic Web - if you read between the flaming, you’ll see I totally endorse her view — what I didn’t like is being tagged (by reference to the Scientific American article) as being a proponent of what she called the “orderly semantic web” — she’s right that the Web of data, with simple interlinked ontologies to describe bits of it, is the important part of the Semantic Web.  Ontologies are actually a valuable tool, but especially when they are linked together and linked to lots of interlinked data - i.e. what Rachel called the “chaotic Semantic Web” — all I’m disagreeing with is her comment, which doesn’t really reduce the value of her argument, that:
   The Intelligent Web is the one evoked by Sir Tim Berners-Lee’s vision in the famous Scientific American article.

because Tim has never supported that view, and I don’t think that article (which I know pretty well) can be used to claim he (or his coauthors) do.

So Rachel, and your many fans and supporters, please accept this apology - if anyone thought I was bashing on your overall point (which is well made, modulo this one point) please reread my screed - you’re absolutely right in your view that the Sem Web is about bringing more things to the Web and creating more links (and network effect).  And to the  emailer who said I shouldn’t compare Rachel to Clay Shirky — believe me, I wasn’t trying to - she gets it, and best I can tell, he still doesn’t.

(btw, sorry this discussion is not in blog comments as it should be, but something is messed up on the blog comment approval for this site - we’re working on it)

quark xpress 6.0 demo crack
personal finance software Download NeuroDimension TradingSolutions 3.1
discount adobe photo shop software
DISCREET EDIT v 6.5 Download Orchid Medical Spa 6.1.1
Mimaki Fine Cut price
Shade 7.1 Pro Download Paloalto Marketing Plan Pro 2006 9.00.0055
BuY ARTCAM
freeway 4 pro for mac Download PaloAlto Business Plan Pro 2007 Premier Edition 9.06
oem full version pc game
adobe download encore Download PC access S7-200
dvdit pro 6.0
PhotoShop Elements 3.0 Plus Premiere Elements Download Pentom AgentOrganizer 2.8.54
3D Maker v1.2
cheap microsoft office uk Download Perpetualbudget system 4.5
quark xpress keyboard shortcut
using algorithmix renovator Download Plaxis Professional 8.2
lipsync studio
financial planning software comparison Download Pointwise 16.0.R2
FL STUDIO 5.0.0
adobe acrobat messenger Download Primavera Project Planner 3.3
buy cheap adobe software
Native Instruments LabVIEW 7.1 Download ProChef Premier 6.0
adobe standard download
adobe software download Download Quest Schema Manager 3.4
cheap Adobe Acrobat Messenger
Premiere Elements 1 Full Version Download Quickbooks Enterprise Solutions 8.0
bay window
discount window blinds Download Quicken 2004 Premier Home And Business
NextLimit.RealFlow
Wildfire 2.0 m090 Download Quicken 2007 Premier Home & Business
quark xpress 5 update
discount Adobe Acrobat 7.0 and older software Download Rental Property Tracker Plus 1.7
diner dash full version
shareware vst Download Sage Instant Accounts 12.0
quark xpress validation codes
creative suite 1.3 Download Rumba Office 7.4
Adobe Creative Suite Premium Edition 2.0 for Mac
5 demo quark xpress Download Salon Iris 6.1
counter strike full version download
microsoft word software price Download Scansoft Paperport Pro Office Deluxe 9
Adobe GoLive CS2 8.0
bentley microstation price Download Scheduling Employees 2000
sprutcam
sonic DLA Download Small Business Inventory Control 5.5
Eyematic FaceStation
download oem full simgirls version Download Small Business Tracker Deluxe 1.7
discount software for teachers
2 adobe creative oem suite Download Smartdraw 2007 8.1
adobe photoshop oem download
microsoft publisher software free download Download Spss 15.0
vista window
adobe photo shop serial Download SPSS Answertree 3.0
20×20 kitchen
oem microsoft office pro Download Stat-Ease Design Expert 7.0
adobe photo shop cs serial
Apple Training SeriesCHM, PDF Download Statsoft Statistica 6.0
business accounting software free
personal finance software review Download Symantec ACT 2005 7.0
full version of zoo tycoon
BuY ARTCAM Download TapeWare 7.0
microsoft software support
quark xpress 4.11 Download TradingSolutions 3.0
the small print tablature format guitar pro
buy cheap Adobe Acrobat 7.0 Professional Download Trados 7 Freelance
adobe premier pro tutorial
quark xpress download Download Utimaco Safeguard Advanced Security 4.3
buy oem AutoCAD
cheap 28040290 Download Wordmagic Translator Professional Plus 5.0
install window
quark xpress 6 crack Download Yukonsoft EBusiness Solutions 7.0
window xp media center upgrade
binary research imaging utility Download 123 Flash Chat Server 6.6
dvdidle pro
vinyl replacement window Download 602LAN Suite 2004.0.06.0830
oem software download
map und guide german 11.0 Download Access2Mysql Pro 5.5
adobe pack photo shop
Alias Mental Ray Standalone Download Acunetix Web Vulnerability Scanner 4
parametric equalization VST 64bit
rgc audio z3ta + Download Active WebCam 9.9
cheap adobe photoshop 7.0
eyebeam licence key Download AdMuncher 4.6
the small print tablature format guitar pro
Acrobat 6.0 Professional Full Retail for Windows Download AdventNet ManageEngine Wifi Manager 5.5
Oasys Suite 9.1a
shadow illuminator 1.0.22 Download Alchemy Network Inventory Pro 4.6
discount software for students
cheap Illustrator Download AnzioWin 15.2
Shade 7.1 Pro
upgrade window 95 to 98 Download Batchsync ftp 2.0
microsoft office xp oem
finance software review Download Broker FTP Server 6
illustrator symbols
CHEAP ARCHITECT Download BWMeter 3.4
navcad
full version game Download Caphyon Advanced Web Ranking 3.1
vba autocad ebook
98 download full version window Download CaptainFTP 4.5 MAC
2 cs photo shop standard
Mainconcept Mpeg Pro 1.06 for premiere Pro Download ClickTracks Analyzer 5.6
adobe photo shop album 2.0
adobe acrobat oem software Download Copernic Agent Professional 6.12
Discounted OEM Microsoft Software
mathcad 13enterprise edition Download DbQwikEdit 2.5.9.98
Oem Macromedia Studio 8.0 (2 cds)
accounting software mac Download CuteFTP 8.1 Professional Edition
adobe photo shop 7.0
press Download Easy Chat Server 2.2
discount adobe acrobat software
Apollo DVD Copy SE 4.2.1 Download Ektron CMS400 NET 6.0
quarkxpress 6.0
Upgrade for Windows Download Ektron eWebEditPro + XML 5.1.0.38
Addweb Website Promoter Pro 8.0.3.8+download -crack -cracks -serial
microsoft office cheapest Download Ektron eWebEditPro 5.1.0.38
cheap PhotoShop CS 2 software
buy cheap Adobe Download Embarcadero DBArtisan 8.1
quark xpress 4
student discount adobe photoshop cs Download EMCO Remote Desktop Pro 2.0
ComponentOne Studio for DotNET
financial accounting software Download FarPoint Spread for Web Forms 3.0
adobe encore template
adobe acrobat 7.0 professional Download FTPEditor Pro 3.3.2
Spruce DVDMaestro
oem full version computer game Download Gammadyne Mailer 31.0
microsoft word software price
bpm studio profesional 4.9 Download GFI FAXmaker for Networks SMTP 12.0
macromedia press actionscript 2
Retail Box Download HeavyMath Cam 3D Webmaster Edition 3.1
cheap software on demand
discount software adobe Download HTTP Analyzer Full Edition 3.0.5
buy CS2 creative suite version 2
window me upgrade Download Ideal Administration 2007 8.1
after effects 6.5
extreme movie manager scripts Download Internet Business Promoter 9.6
finance software for pocket pc
Acid 5.0c Download Iron Speed Designer Enterprise 4.2
business accounting software comparison
luxology modo 1.03 Download IsMail Pro 2.3.891
full version gamez
adobe cs2 photo shop software Download JShop Professional 3.03
microsoft software downloads
macromedia flash software free Download Kerio Win Route 6.3
acrobat 7.0 pro upgrade software
4 indesign version Download ManageEngine OpManager 7.0
full pro version window xp
illustrator cs tutorials Download PagePromoter 5.2
quark xpress 6.5 review
bcad for tablet Download Shopping Cart Professional 6.09
3DMeNow Pro
terramodel Download Solarwinds Orion Network Performance Monitor Slx Edition 8.5
encore lyrics
Mainconcept Mpeg Pro 1.06 for premiere Pro Download SQL Server Backup 6.1
peachtree accounting software free download
buy femap Download WebPosition Gold Pro 2.0
window media 10
toonz 4.5 Download Zend Studio 5.1
lingvosoft 3.1.29
diablo full version download Download 123 DVD Converter 4.6.0
window xp upgrade problem
window media center Download 321 Video Converter v1.2
quark xpress 6 serial
logocad triga Download A-One DVD Copy v5.81
Honestech Vhs To Dvd 2.0
adobe standard 6 Download A-Z AVI DivX XviD Converter v5.8
adobe photo shop 7 tutorial
quark xpress 6.5 update Download Absolute Video Splitter Joiner v1.8
synful orchestra
creative suite 2.0 Download Acala DVD Ripper v2.9.1
quarkxpress 5
student discount adobe photoshop cs Download Acoustica Premium Edition v4.0
VirtualLNK Business Icons
ebook adobe golive cs2 Download Adobe Audition 1.5
Sonic DLA
window security Download Adobe Encore DVD 1.5
window media
full version of zoo tycoon Download Adobe Premiere Elements 1.0
acrobat pro 7
98 full se version window Download Adobe Premiere PRO 2.0
adobe premiere elements
iron speed 2.0 Download Aestesis Elektronika Live 2.12
East-Tec Eraser 2005 Professional 6.1.0.104
access after denied upgrade window xp Download Amadis AVI DIVX XVID to DVD Creator 1.1
photo shop elements 3.0 download
glo absynth Download Amond DVD Ripper v2.3
adobe premier pro 1.5
2 cs photo shop standard Download Antares Kantos VST RTAS 1.0

adobe cs2 photo shop total training Buy Adobe InDesign CS4 + Extra Content microsoft office 2003 oem
locate software oem files Buy Autodesk Architectural Desktop 2006 Widows oem software window software oem 862.
“window 2000 upgrade download” Buy Microsoft Office Enterprise 2007 German quark xpress 6 crack,
oem software bundle Buy Corel WordPerfect Office X4 “software oem italiano”
adobe photo shop element Buy Discreet 3D Studio MAX 7.0 oem software cds
microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Buy Adobe Acrobat 7.0 Pro cheap software downloads
oem Microsoft Office Buy Adobe Dreamweaver CS3 adobe standard encoding
oem office 2000 software; Buy Macromedia Flash Professional 8 MAC upgrade window 2000 to xp
dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4, Buy Symantec Winfax Pro 10 inkjet definition oem software
The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6! Buy Adobe Lightroom 2.0 financial planning software australia
Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Buy Microsoft Publisher 2003 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52!
software oem cd line business Buy Adobe After Effects 7 adobe cs2 photo shop total training
microsoft office 2003 oem Buy Adobe InDesign CS2 v4.0 locate software oem files
Widows oem software window software oem 862. Buy Adobe Dreamweaver CS4 MAC “window 2000 upgrade download”
quark xpress 6 crack, Buy Adobe Photoshop CS3 Extended MAC oem software bundle
“software oem italiano” Buy Corel Designer Technical Suite 12.0 adobe photo shop element
oem software cds Buy Adobe Photoshop CS3 Extended microsoft window 2000 professional oem software
cheap software downloads Buy Norton AntiVirus 2008 oem Microsoft Office
adobe standard encoding Buy Adobe InDesign CS2 v4.0 oem office 2000 software;
upgrade window 2000 to xp Buy Adobe Fireworks CS3 dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4,
inkjet definition oem software Buy Microsoft Expression Studio 2.0 The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6!
financial planning software australia Buy Nero 6 Ultra Edition Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2

This entry was posted on Sunday, November 25th, 2007 at 9:08 pm and is filed under MINDSWAP news. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.